A letter from Rhino Times Reader “Professor”
I recently learned of a story from earlier this year and find myself needing to defend a 10-year-old’s proposal for a $5,000 electric-vehicle rebate. Not because I support EVs but because of how a NC elected representative chose to respond when a fourth grader did something we should be encouraging every young American to do: learn about an issue, form an opinion, write to his representative and respectfully make his case.
Ten-year-old Christian Mango wrote to Rep. Virginia Foxx suggesting a $5,000 federal rebate for people who purchase an electric vehicle. Rep. Foxx was perfectly entitled to disagree. She could have explained why she believes such a subsidy would be poor public policy. She could have thanked Christian for taking the time to write and encouraged him to keep learning about the issue.
Instead, she went after his teacher.
Foxx told the fourth grader to ask his teacher to explain “propaganda” to him and suggested that his teachers were more interested in “indoctrinating” him than providing a good education. (Note: the teacher didn’t suggest what the subject of his letter should be about)
Think about that for a moment. A 10-year-old wrote a letter to his congresswoman expressing an opinion about public policy, and the response from a member of Congress was essentially to tell him that his teachers had brainwashed him. That isn’t how we teach children about representative government. It is how we teach them to be afraid of expressing an opinion that challenges someone in power.
And let’s be clear: Christian didn’t demand that Foxx agree with him. He didn’t insult her. He didn’t threaten her. He didn’t even send her an angry political rant. He apparently did exactly what we tell young people they should do, participate in our democracy.
If Rep. Foxx believes the EV rebate is bad policy, she should make that case. Explain the cost. Explain the alternatives. Explain the national debt. Give the child an opportunity to learn something from the disagreement. But attacking the teacher who apparently encouraged students to research an issue and participate in civic discourse crosses a very different line.
There is something especially troubling about an adult in a position of political power using that power to lecture a 10-year-old about “indoctrination” simply because the child reached a conclusion she didn’t like.
We constantly hear politicians say that America’s children are our future. If that’s true, perhaps we should encourage them to write their representatives rather than teach them that their representatives might ridicule their teachers when they do.
Let’s hope for change this mid-term and elect leaders who know how to be the adults in the room versus showing kids how ugly they can be to push an agenda based on conspiracy theories and misinformation.

Another politician who stayed too long at the dance.
Way too long she is running an ad from 20 years ago, she is 83 years old
I think showing her as young and vibrant is misleading
We don’t need to subsidize rich people to purchase their vehicles.
That isn’t the point of the letter.
But why do you assume only rich people buy cars?
We don’t need to subsidize ANYONE to buy ANY vehicles (or houses, or insurance, or education). Foxx may not have been polite, but she was right. A fourth grader doesn’t come up with woke ideas on his own.
His parents surely helped. Do you not think parents helping with homework is a good thing?
So you think it’s fine that the parents are teaching the child to be dependent on the government and mooch off the taxpayers? Yeah, you would favor that.
No. I think it is cool for parents to teach their kids that to drive a critical change in a deep-rooted cultural behavior sometimes requires government investment that benefits our future generations against things like Climate change.
What I do take offense at is a political leader of our community using conspiracy theories to shame a teacher just because the student has different political opinions that she does.
Hope that helps, but you be you.
Cheers
So her treating a child this way is okay with. Regardless of the issue?
Fox’s behavior and letter was totally inappropriate. It was immature, catty, and judgmental.
Sadly, I have seen this behavior among our local counsel, judges, city/county council.
Change starts at the top, and it’s past time to clean house… drain the swamp.
These letters always come up at election time!
A member of Congress should be able to withstand political disagreement without directing the force of her public office toward the person who helped a child participate in the civic process.
If a teacher encouraged a student to write to his elected representative, that shouldn’t be treated as suspect merely because the student’s views are unpopular with the elected official.
The issue is what lesson we teach children about speaking to those in power. Do we want them to learn that they can respectfully contact their representatives, ask questions, and express their opinions? Or do we want them to wonder whether speaking out could draw unwanted attention to the adults who encouraged them? The first option is correct.
Members of Congress have enormous platforms and considerable influence. They should use that influence to encourage civic participation—not make people think twice.
Just an FYI. I have written to 4 of our folks in the U.S. Congress and the NC General Assembly about license plate readers. None of them have responded to my concerns.
Well said SaltLife.
What’s wrong with license plate readers? If it helps catch crooks, I’m all for it.
My disapproval of license plate readers (LPRs) has nothing to do with resisting police investigations into crime. My concerns are privacy, mass surveillance, long-term tracking, data retention, accuracy, who can access this information and with whom it is shared, false hits and mistakes, and abuse by agencies that obtain this data.
Police already can read license plates, but should the government automatically create and retain a searchable record of where virtually every vehicle travels? A police officer manually checking a license plate is not the same as an automated network continuously collecting and retaining location data on vehicles.
No matter what Flock says, these cameras are not just a one-picture snapshot like the old Polaroid print cameras. They are Artificial Intelligence machines meant to be shared beyond law enforcement.
A Kansas Police Chief admitted to repeatedly using the Flock system to locate vehicles belonging to his ex-girlfriend and her boyfriend in 2023.
Another former Kansas police officer was convicted of computer crime and stalking in 2023 after he logged in to the Flock database to track his estranged wife.
A Charlotte-Mecklenburg police officer was arrested for sharing information obtained through the Flock camera system with the subject of a drug investigation.
A Missouri police officer used the Flock camera system to stalk his wife during their divorce.
An Arizona police officer resigned for abusing LPR data to stalk his estranged wife. A Haines City, Florida police officer was arrested for using LPRs to stalk his estranged wife. Five Albany, GA officers were arrested for Flock misuse.
Four Savannah, GA police officers and two civilian employees have been fired for unauthorized personal searches within the department’s Flock LPR system. One officer allegedly turned over system access to a third party.
A Mooresville, NC police officer has been fired and arrested after she improperly used the Flock LPR system dozens of times to track her boyfriend’s ex-wife. The police chief also said other officers are under investigation for possible misuse of the camera system.
A Pasadena, CA police sergeant has surrendered his law enforcement license for using LPRs to track a fellow female officer.
A New Bedford, MA police officer has been placed on leave for using LPR data to track his ex-girlfriend.
You get the picture (no pun intended). But who are the real criminals? Maybe we need more cameras to monitor police officers.
A Flock LPR in Wisconsin flagged a silver SUV as connected to a homicide investigation. Police boxed in the vehicle and detained its occupants at gunpoint. Just one problem: the alert was in error, and the vehicle was no longer wanted in the investigation. This automated alert subjected innocent people to a high-risk police stop that could easily have ended in tragedy.
An innocent couple was held at gunpoint and handcuffed while their 6-week-old baby was left in a car seat by police in Sherwood, Arkansas, after a Flock camera misread their license plate.
An incident involving a resident of Lenexa, Kansas, was targeted by the local police department using LPRs after he wrote a critical op-ed about the police department.
Wow, SaltLife and I agree again! Great summary of the issue.
Lindsey Isaacs, a 23-year-old woman from Florida, spent 13 days in jail after an automated Flock Safety license plate reader (LPR) camera system misidentified her vehicle in connection with a fatal crash.
————-
Automatic License Plate Readers are a literal manifestation of “Big Brother is Watching You”.
Anyone who supports them is either incredibly naive or a zealous advocate of omnipotent omniscient government – also known as… a Leftist.
—————–
Old news. And Virginia Foxx relates the event differently.
As Her Majesty put it, “Recollections may vary”.
The letter is public and says what it says. How is she denying that?
Oh that’s right, you say Na Uh and expect everyone to just take your word for it…..hint…..we don’t.
————-
I had called her about the slant that WGHP Fox8 was putting on the story. She called me back and refuted several of their implications, and thanked me for my support.
You going to keep what she refuted a secret because her letter was made public and she very clearly did as my letter outlines? She ignored a childs public outreach to their representative and instead fabricated that the teacher was ‘indoctrinating’ him….. How do you reframe that as ‘slant’ by the news source? The letter said what it said.
——————
Hey Chrissy! (his real name) This is a big nothingburger! The story’s 3 months old and it was nothing in the first place.
Some kid wrote a letter, got a response he didn’t like. His obviously far Left “educator” decided to try to make it an issue.
I don’t know who’s more pathetic as you grasp at straws to score a political point – the “educator”, or you.
And did you know you can get more topical and current news in the daily paper? You should try it.
Oh right, you don’t care about how our leaders use conspiracy theories to disparage education of our children in our State. Got it. Thanks for sharing.
Cheers Chappy Happy
——————–
“Professor” believes that anyone who fails to toe the Democrat Party line is a conspiracy theorist.
Or a racist.
Or a bigot.
Or uneducated.
Or wears a tin foil hat.
Then claims that WE are prejudiced!
Austin putting words in mouths people yet again with no basis of truth or fact. Never trust a conservative to tell what a liberal thinks and never trust a liberal to tell you what a conservative thinks. Judge them by what they say and do.
Here is what I actually believe:
Anyone who promotes an idea without evidence is a conspiracy theorist.
Bigots are those that judge billions of people based on the actions of a few just because of where they were born, the color of the skin, or their religious beliefs…..or….judge people negatively just because they are different or in the minority.
Racists are those that believe some races are less evolved than others.
Hope that helps.
Cheers Doodle Dandy Dude
—————
But you believe in God, without evidence, don’t you?
Are you a conspiracy theorist?
I witness the evidence of God every day in his creations of Life on Earth. Evidence doesn’t have to be direct to be meaningful or to be important to supporting your opinion or beliefs.
Are you asking for my testimony? Happy to share if interested.
—————
So it’s okay to believe in some things without concrete evidence, but not others.
Got it.
Better Headline.
“Educator” pushes child to write GOP Congresswoman, seeks publicity to smear reply.
The teacher didn’t have anything to do with the letter from Foxx going to the news. The kids’ parents took the story to the news and rightfully so. Do you think her response was appropriate? Do you think her response wasn’t newsworthy given her treatment of both the child and the teacher?
The teacher gave a simple open-ended assignment. She didn’t tell him what to write about, or who to write it to….yet Foxx claimed it was propaganda and indoctrination? Guess you are so team loyal to Republicans you think trying to teach children in school about representative government is indoctrination since the kid doesn’t agree with what your told to believe by your conservative members in Congress. Only thing Foxx taught the kid was that she doesn’t care about him, his teacher or his opinion.
Is that what you think is the appropriate response?
Also, how did Congresswoman Foxx attack the 4th Grader? With a stick? A Switch? Her fists?
Or does the headline mean that Foxx took the opportunity to criticize the teacher who had put the child up to this stunt? Is Foxx not allowed to reply to letters in a critical way?
Did the child REALLY write the letter or did it come from mom and or dad? Asking for a friend. 🙂
————-
It came from the “educator”, obviously.
Ten year olds who haven’t been subjected to political indoctrination don’t write letters to their Congressman.
They play softball, hide & seek, and ride their bicycles.
The teacher gave the assignment to write their representative on any issue of their choice. You think maybe the parents helped their child with homework? You know, like good parents do by being involved in their kids education? Duh.
Conservatives really do hate education. Not shocked since Trump likes to say “smart people don’t like me”.
But you be you.
Most 10 year olds write just fine. Fair to assume it is a topic he discussed with parenta amd was heavily influenced by them as is expected.
But weird to think the teacher had anything to do with anything other than presenting the challenge as a learning opportunity.
Only a narrow mind conservative who think a teacher teaching kids about representative government is a ‘stunt’.
Not shocked seeing that come from al hare.
Don’t forget, Trump said smart people don’t like him for a reason.
Cheers
—————–
You keep clinging to that snippet, buddy.
According to you, the multi-millionaire who became the President of the United States is as thick as a brick – but you’re a genius.
Yeah, you’re such a genius that you have to claim to be a professor, so as to impress us all, when the truth is that you’re a little wanker who’s desperately insecure and doesn’t have a life.
You’re pathetic.
Yeah, the idiot who wrote a long rant about not being awarded the Nobel Peace prize the same year he started an unnecessary war by invading Iran.
Again, I remind the MAGA cults members that Trump inherited over $400 million dollars from his daddy. He didn’t become a multi-millionaire by hard work. He was born a multi-millionaire. And now he is abusing his power by directing millions of dollars of YOUR tax dollars to his kids businesses while at the same time robbing millions from his followers with a crypto scam.
Trump isn’t smart, he just lacks the morals that to stop himself from grifting everyone around him….and he is one hell of a grifter.
Cheers Diddy Dandy Doo
——————–
Careful “Professor”, your “hate” is showing.
Juas telling the truth dear boy.
Cheers
—————
That must be “Your Truth”… as Democrats say.
Feel free to point out anything factually incorrect in my statement about Trump.
Cheers Doodle Dude Hoo Hoo
Does the Professor want Iran to have a nuke?
————————-
Lots of circular reasoning there, buddy.
Trump is “an idiot”. “Trump isn’t smart”. Therefore Trump is stupid.
When you assert your conclusion as a premise, it’s flawed logic.
But then, logic isn’t your strong point, is it?
Iran was a hostile adversary, but hostility is not the same as an imminent threat to the United States. Trump’s administration presented no credible public evidence that Iran was on the verge of launching an attack on American soil, and the IAEA’s assessment did not support claims that Iran was days or weeks away from building a nuclear bomb.
Preventing a potential future threat is not the same as responding to an imminent one, particularly when diplomatic alternatives remain. Trump needed to demonstrate why war was necessary now…..not simply argue that Iran might become more dangerous someday.
It is truly amazing how Trump and his followers went from accusing every democrat opponent of being a war monger to being war mongers themselves.
But you be you
It’s difficult to predict which elected officials would respond to a fourth grader’s letter in the most “appropriate” way to satisfy everyone. I think suggesting that his teacher instruct students on propaganda and indoctrination related to political issues is a positive idea. It’s a subject more students need to be educated about before graduating.
The actual letter Christian wrote wasn’t shown in any of the articles released at the time, although the one from Rep. Foxx was. Her response (which may have been written by an intern, as many letters are) did address the issues Christian mentioned in his letter. She gave her reasons for why tax rebates would hurt lower-income people, why favoring one automobile over another wasn’t a good idea, and why government regulations over auto manufacturing should be reconsidered. She also told him that she was sharing information about climate change in links he could study. She did say she thought his teacher was indoctrinating him on this issue, which wasn’t a fair assumption. It may be that the lack of information about why he was writing a letter advocating EV rebates and their possible impact on the climate. I think she responded the way a mature educator would, albeit her vocabulary and tone were more suited for an older child. I certainly don’t think anything she said warranted the uproar that resulted.
I appreciate Virginia Foxx’s representation in the US House. I’m pleased she’s running again. It’s interesting to me that you brought up this minor incident over five months after it occurred and had been discussed thoroughly. It’s not a campaign deal-maker or breaker.
I can’t disagree more. The real insult was to the teacher to public educators as a whole by my making the implication that the teacher directed the content of the letter (the teacher didn’t) and pushed a false narrative of teacher indoctrinating kids. Christian’s mother had it right when she stated that “Foxx attacked his teacher, his school, his education”. Frankly it seems like Foxx is trying to indoctrinate the kid to not trust his own education all because the young man (and most likely his parents) has a different view on EVs.
A truly pathetic act by an elected official pushing unjustified accusations against our public education system. This is especially appalling given that Foxx is the chair of the House Education and the Workforce committee.
Cheers
——————-
Thanks Deborah, for a reasoned and articulate commentary.
The fake Professor has become so desperate to score points that he’s gone back 5 months for this one! And he’s so fixated with me that he’ll throw three year old previous comments of mine back in my face.
what a sorry little guy.
Foxx missed the opportunity to educate a young citizen. She actually launched a politically charged accusation against the teachers. Foxx is known for having a Bull Persona. She’s 83 and shouldn’t be in Congress.
And I’m sorry William missed my point about writing letters to 4 people about LPRs. My point is that none of my representatives in the State and federal legislature bother to respond to me. Sad state of affairs.
It seems that voices and votes don’t really matter.
Enough. No one cares about this story anymore.
Ten year olds need to shut up and eat their vegetables.
Seems your lacking some brain foods.
— Says someone whose comment is: “Seems YOUR (sic) lacking some brain foods”.
So, who’s the stupid one here, Effy?
.
PS
You’re a public school teacher, aren’t you? Or a former one, I bet.